Should I RUST Or Should I GO?
- Pascal Van Dam
- Sep 11, 2023
- 14 min read
Updated: Nov 29, 2023
A showdown: the crucial exposed, choices clarified while your business' tech future hangs in the balance ... 💻💲
First Things First
Choosing the right programming language for your projects and business can be a critical decision. Two contenders, Rust and Go (or Golang), have gained popularity for their unique strengths. In this blog post, we'll dive into the Rust vs. Go debate, exploring their key business benefits & technical features, advantages of implementation, challenges, use cases, future trends to watch for and implications of this all for both DevOps professionals and Business Decision Makers. So you can make an informed choice to propel your business forward!
A Glance On Rust & Go
Rust and Go are both modern programming languages that can help you build simple, secure, scalable, and reliable applications on Kubernetes. They have many features and benefits that make them attractive choices for developing cloud-native applications. By using Rust or Go with Kubernetes, you can take advantage of the flexibility, portability, and efficiency of both technologies
For DevOps: Rust is a systems programming language known for its emphasis on safety and low-level control. It's ideal for building performance-critical applications and has a strong focus on preventing memory-related bugs. Go, also known as Golang, is a statically typed and compiled programming language. It is recognized for its simplicity, concurrency1 support, and efficient garbage collection2. Go is well-suited for building scalable web services and cloud-native applications.
For Business Decision Makers: Rust's emphasis on safety can reduce the risk of costly security breaches and system failures, making it a suitable choice for projects where reliability is paramount. Go's simplicity and efficiency can lead to faster development cycles, reducing time-to-market and operational costs. Its concurrency features facilitate building responsive and scalable software systems.
TECHTALK MADE SIMPLE
1 Concurrency in Go (in Simple Terms): In Go, concurrency is like having multiple chefs in the kitchen, each working on different dishes at once. Go's built-in features make it easy for these "chefs" (goroutines) to collaborate efficiently, serving up tasks faster and improving your application's responsiveness without waiting for one task to finish before starting another.
2 Garbage Collection in Go (in Simple Terms): In Go, garbage collection is like having a diligent cleaner in your office. It quietly and automatically removes unused resources (like memory) so your Go programs can stay clutter-free and perform at their best. It's like having a neat and tidy workspace for your code to run smoothly.
Why Does This Matter?
Cloud-native technology represents a modern approach to developing and running software applications in the cloud. It's important because it enables businesses to harness the full potential of the cloud, fostering agility and innovation. By breaking applications into smaller, manageable components and using containerization and orchestration tools like Kubernetes, cloud-native solutions allow for rapid development, scalability, and efficient resource utilization. This not only accelerates time-to-market but also enhances reliability, resilience, and cost-efficiency, helping businesses stay competitive and adapt swiftly to evolving market demands. In short, going cloud-native empowers companies to thrive in the digital age.
Rust and Go have some advantages over other languages when it comes to working with Kubernetes. For example:
Rust and Go are both compiled languages, which means they produce a single static binary that can be easily containerized and deployed on Kubernetes. They also have low memory footprints and high performance, which are important for running efficient and scalable applications on Kubernetes.
Rust and Go both have excellent support for concurrency, which allows them to handle multiple tasks simultaneously and leverage the power of multi-core processors. This is useful for building applications that can handle high-throughput and low-latency requests on Kubernetes.
Rust and Go both have strong type systems and error handling mechanisms, which help prevent many common bugs and ensure the reliability and security of the applications. They also have good documentation, testing, benchmarking, and profiling frameworks, which help improve the quality and maintainability of the code.
Rust and Go both have vibrant communities and ecosystems, which provide many libraries, tools, frameworks, and resources for developing applications on Kubernetes. They also have active contributors and users who share their knowledge and experience with others.
Key Concepts
Let's break down the essential concepts related to cloud-native technology (More on Kubernetes Architecture Go here!). These concepts are foundational to cloud-native technology, enabling businesses to build, deploy, and manage modern applications that are scalable, resilient, and agile in response to evolving market needs.
Containers: Containers are lightweight, standalone, and executable packages that include everything needed to run a piece of software, including the code, runtime, system tools, libraries, and settings. Importance: Containers provide consistency and portability across different environments, making it easier to develop, test, and deploy applications. They enable efficient resource utilization and can run on any infrastructure, whether on-premises or in the cloud.
Microservices: Microservices is an architectural approach where an application is divided into smaller, independent services that can be developed, deployed, and scaled independently. Each service focuses on a specific function. Importance: Microservices promote agility and flexibility in software development. They allow for faster development cycles, easy scaling of individual components, and improved fault isolation, leading to more resilient and maintainable applications.
Orchestration (e.g., Kubernetes): Orchestration refers to the automated management of containerized applications. Kubernetes is a popular orchestration platform that handles tasks like deploying, scaling, load balancing, and managing containerized workloads. Importance: Orchestration simplifies the management of complex containerized applications. It ensures that containers are running as desired, optimizes resource allocation, and automates scaling to meet changing demands, enhancing application availability and efficiency.
"A Kubernetes Architect's Guide to Aligning Technical and Business Goals"
This is not just a book, its your roadmap to transforming Code to Ca$h...
Both Rust and Go offer unique strengths for cloud-native technology, allowing businesses to choose the language that best aligns with their specific project/business requirements and performance goals. Here's a brief breakdown of essential concepts related to Rust and Go in the context of cloud-native technology:
Rust:
Containers: Rust is suitable for building components within containers due to its strong memory safety and low-level control, making it secure and efficient.
Microservices: Rust's performance and reliability make it a solid choice for critical microservices where safety and speed are paramount.
Orchestration: Rust can be used in orchestration tools or critical system components thanks to its focus on memory safety and control.
Go (Golang):
Containers: Go's simplicity and efficient runtime make it a strong contender for containerized applications, simplifying development and deployment.
Microservices: Go's built-in concurrency support and ease of use make it ideal for building scalable microservices.
Orchestration: Go is well-suited for developing tools and components that can be integrated into orchestration systems like Kubernetes, enhancing overall system performance.
Benefits
In highlights, Rust offers enhanced security, high performance, and reliability, making it an excellent choice for applications demanding top-tier safety and performance. Go, on the other hand, provides ease of learning, efficient concurrency, and cost-effective scalability, making it a pragmatic choice for building cloud-native applications and microservices.
Advantages Of Adopting Rust:
Enhanced Security: Rust's strong type system and memory safety features reduce the risk of common programming errors, such as null pointer dereferences and buffer overflows. This leads to more secure applications, protecting businesses from data breaches and vulnerabilities.
High Performance: Rust's focus on low-level control and optimization makes it suitable for high-performance applications, particularly in industries like gaming and IoT. This can result in faster, more efficient software systems.
Reliability: Rust's ownership system ensures strict control over memory management, reducing the likelihood of crashes and system failures. This reliability is crucial for businesses in sectors where downtime is costly, such as finance and healthcare.
Community and Ecosystem: Rust has a growing and active community, providing valuable resources, libraries, and tools. This ecosystem support accelerates development and reduces time-to-market.
Advantages of Adopting Go (Golang):
Ease of Learning: Go's simple and minimalistic syntax, along with a small set of features, makes it easy for developers to learn and adopt quickly. This results in faster development cycles and reduced training costs for businesses.
Concurrent Programming: Go's built-in concurrency support through goroutines allows developers to write highly concurrent code effortlessly. This is beneficial for applications that require responsiveness and scalability, such as web services and microservices.
Efficiency and Scalability: Go's efficient runtime and low memory footprint make it suitable for resource-constrained environments, making it cost-effective for cloud-native applications and deployment on Kubernetes.
Community and Tools: Go boasts a strong and growing community, along with a rich ecosystem of libraries and tools. This ensures ongoing support, maintenance, and access to essential resources for businesses and developers
For DevOps: Rust excels in system-level programming, providing fine-grained control over hardware resources, making it suitable for developing operating systems, drivers, and game engines. Go prioritizes simplicity, making it a good fit for building scalable web services.
For Business Decision Makers: Rust's performance can lead to faster and more efficient software systems, while Go's simplicity can accelerate project development and reduce operational costs.
Challenges
When implementing Rust or Go, businesses must weigh the advantages of these languages against the challenges and considerations relevant to their needs. Rust offers strong safety and control but requires a steep learning curve, while Go prioritizes simplicity and concurrency but may have trade-offs in certain advanced scenarios. The choice should align with the specific goals and constraints of your business needs.
Common Challenges and Considerations when Implementing Rust:
Learning Curve: Rust's strict ownership model3 and borrowing system4 can be challenging for developers new to the language. Businesses should account for a learning curve, which may affect initial development timelines.
Availability of Expertise: Finding experienced Rust developers may be more challenging than with more widely adopted languages. Training and upskilling may be required.
Ecosystem Maturity: While Rust's ecosystem is growing, it may not have as many libraries and tools as more established languages. Businesses should evaluate whether the required resources are available.
Concurrency Complexity: While Rust offers strong concurrency support, writing concurrent code can be intricate. Developers need to be proficient in handling concurrency safely.
Integration with Legacy Code: Integrating Rust with existing codebases written in other languages can pose challenges. Interoperability5 may require additional effort.
TECHTALK MADE SIMPLE
3 Rust's Ownership Model (in Simple Terms): In Rust, ownership is like being the boss of your own toys. You get to decide who can play with them and when they need to be put away. This strict ownership model ensures that resources are used efficiently and prevents "toy" (memory) mishandling, which keeps your Rust programs safe and reliable. 4 Rust's Borrowing System (in Simple Terms): Rust's borrowing system is like letting a friend borrow your bike but with strict rules. Your friend can use it, but they can't damage it, and they have to return it when they're done. This ensures that resources are shared safely and nothing gets broken, making your Rust programs secure and robust.
5 Interoperability (in Simple Terms): Interoperability is like different brands of building blocks fitting together to build a bigger and better structure. In programming, it means that different technologies or software components can work seamlessly together, sharing information and functionality. It's like making sure your Lego bricks can connect with your friend's Lego bricks to build something amazing.
Common Challenges and Considerations when Implementing Go (Golang):
Simplicity vs. Control: Go's simplicity, while an advantage, may limit low-level control needed for certain applications. Businesses should assess whether Go's level of control aligns with their requirements.
Garbage Collection: Go employs a garbage collector, which, although lightweight and efficient, can still impact application performance during garbage collection cycles. Consider this when designing real-time or resource-intensive systems.
Dependency Management: Historically, Go lacked a mature dependency management system6. While this has improved, managing dependencies can still be a consideration in complex projects.
Type System Trade-offs: Go's type system7, while easy to grasp, lacks some advanced features found in other languages. This can limit expressiveness in certain scenarios.
Community and Ecosystem: While Go has a robust community and ecosystem, some specialized domains may have fewer libraries and tools. Businesses should evaluate whether Go can meet their specific needs.
TECHTALK MADE SIMPLE
6 Dependency Management System (in Simple Terms): Think of a dependency management system as a shopping list for your software. It helps your program know what other pieces it needs to work correctly. Just like you wouldn't forget to buy ingredients for a recipe, this system ensures your software has all the necessary parts from the store (libraries and code) to run smoothly.
7 Go's Type System (in Simple Terms): In Go, the type system is like sorting tools into labeled boxes. Each tool has its own box, and you can see at a glance what's inside. This helps Go programs understand what kind of data they're working with, making code more organized and reliable, just like a neatly arranged toolbox.
For DevOps: Rust's learning curve can be steep due to its strict safety features. Go may not be the best choice for CPU-bound tasks.
For Business Decision Makers: The learning curve for Rust may impact initial development timelines, and Go's limitations in CPU-bound scenarios may require additional optimization efforts.
Use Cases
Just as each business has unique needs, so do programming languages. Rust excels in scenarios where memory safety and low-level control are paramount, such as building Kubernetes components and securing critical systems. On the other hand, Go is a strong choice for scenarios that prioritize simplicity, scalability, and efficient resource utilization, making it an excellent fit for building microservices and Kubernetes-related tooling. The choice between Rust and Go should align with the specific requirements and priorities of each use case.
Rust:
Building Kubernetes Components: Rust's focus on memory safety and low-level control makes it an ideal choice for developing Kubernetes components. These components require robust security and reliability to ensure the overall stability of Kubernetes clusters.
Security-Critical Systems: For security-critical systems, such as those found in financial institutions or healthcare, Rust's memory safety features are crucial. It reduces the risk of vulnerabilities and potential breaches, which is paramount in industries where data integrity is non-negotiable.
High-Performance Applications: Rust's efficiency and fine-grained control over hardware resources make it an excellent fit for high-performance applications. In Kubernetes clusters, this can lead to faster and more efficient software systems, optimizing resource usage and performance.
Go (Golang):
Scalable Microservices: Go's simplicity and built-in concurrency support make it an excellent choice for building scalable microservices. These microservices are essential for modern cloud-native applications, where rapid scaling and responsiveness are key.
Resource-Constrained Environments: Go's efficient runtime and low memory footprint make it a cost-effective choice for resource-constrained environments. This efficiency is particularly valuable in Kubernetes clusters, where optimizing resource usage can lead to significant cost savings.
Kubernetes Tooling: Go's ecosystem and native support for Docker and Kubernetes make it a natural fit for developing tools and components within the Kubernetes ecosystem. This simplifies containerization and orchestration tasks, reducing development cycles and operational costs.
Here we have listed the real-world scenarios and applications where both options shine, focusing on distinctive information that can help make a better decision for Kubernetes-related development:
For DevOps: Rust shines in critical systems, IoT devices, and game development. Go is well-suited for web services, cloud-native applications, and microservices.
For Business Decision Makers: Tailor your language choice to your business specific requirements to optimize performance and resource allocation.
Future Trends
The tech landscape is ever-evolving, and staying ahead of the curve is crucial for businesses and professionals alike. Let's explore how languages like Rust and Go are poised for growth, offering unique advantages to meet the challenges of tomorrow. For business decision-makers, we emphasize the importance of keeping a watchful eye on language trends to ensure that your projects & business remains competitive, secure, and aligned with the dynamic demands of the digital age.
For DevOps:
The landscape of systems programming is undergoing significant changes, driven by the increasing demand for security, reliability, and performance. Rust and Go stand at the forefront of this evolution, each with its unique strengths poised for growth.
Rust, with its emphasis on memory safety and control, is gaining traction in industries where security is paramount. Its adoption is growing in sectors like finance, healthcare, and automotive, where software reliability can make or break a business. As the need for secure and efficient systems continues to rise, Rust is positioned to play an increasingly critical role in the DevOps toolkit.
Go, on the other hand, is thriving in the cloud-native ecosystem. With the shift towards microservices, containers, and Kubernetes, Go's simplicity and concurrency support are in high demand. As the cloud-native paradigm becomes the standard for modern application development, Go's growth is set to continue.
In the evolving landscape of systems programming, DevOps professionals should closely monitor how Rust and Go adapt to industry trends. Rust's focus on security and Go's efficiency in scalable architectures make them valuable assets for the future of DevOps.
For Business Decision Makers:
Staying informed about language trends is crucial to ensuring your projects remain competitive and secure in a rapidly evolving tech landscape. As the demand for specialized solutions grows, the choice between Rust and Go can have a significant impact on your organization's success.
Rust's strong focus on security and memory safety positions it well in industries where data protection and system reliability are paramount. Keeping an eye on Rust's adoption in sectors like finance and healthcare can help you make informed decisions about the security of your applications.
Conversely, Go's dominance in the cloud-native ecosystem means that it plays a pivotal role in the development of scalable, responsive, and cost-effective solutions. Monitoring its growth and adoption trends can guide your choices in building modern applications and services.
Remaining attuned to language trends, particularly the evolution and adoption of Rust and Go, is essential for business decision-makers. These languages offer distinct advantages, and understanding their positioning in the tech landscape is crucial for making informed choices that align with your organization's goals and future-proof your projects.
Case Study
In this paragraph, we present some examples of companies and domains that most currently use Rust and Go, intended to help you understand the benefits and challenges of each language, and how they can fit your needs as a DevOps or a Business Decision Maker.
Some of the businesses and industries that use Rust are:
Technology platforms: Mozilla, Microsoft, AWS, Dropbox, Cloudflare, and Figma are some of the big names that use Rust for various projects, such as web browsers, cloud services, file synchronization engines, edge computing, and design tools. They chose Rust because of its memory safety, speed, and efficiency.
Gaming: Rust is also used by game developers, such as Chucklefish, Embark Studios, Ready at Dawn, and Paradox Interactive . They use Rust to create game engines, graphics, physics, networking, and scripting. Rust helps them avoid common bugs and crashes that can ruin the gaming experience.
Blockchain: Rust is a popular choice for blockchain development, as it offers low-level control, concurrency, and cryptography. Some of the projects that use Rust are Polkadot, Solana, Near Protocol, Zcash, and Parity . They use Rust to build scalable, secure, and interoperable blockchain platforms.
Some of the businesses and industries that use Go are:
Technology platforms: Google, Uber, Twitch, Dailymotion, SendGrid, and SoundCloud are some of the well-known companies that use Go for their core services. They use Go because of its simplicity, concurrency, scalability, and productivity.
Cloud computing: Go is widely used for cloud computing applications (both commercially and big open source projects) such as Kubernetes, Docker, CockroachDB, Terraform, and Istio . They use Go to create distributed systems that can run on multiple servers and handle large amounts of data.
Machine learning: Go is also used for machine learning projects, such as TensorFlow, Gorgonia, Gonum, and Seldon . They use Go to implement algorithms, models, and frameworks that can perform complex computations and learn from data.
As you can see from these examples, Rust and Go are both powerful and versatile languages that can be used for a variety of domains and purposes. However, they also have different trade-offs and challenges that you need to consider before choosing one over the other.
For DevOps:
Understanding the landscape of companies and domains currently leveraging Rust and Go offers valuable insights into the technical advantages of these languages. Rust excels in ensuring memory safety, speed, and efficiency. Game developers harness Rust's power to create bug-free gaming experiences. In the blockchain arena, Rust offers low-level control and robust security. On the other hand, Go shines with its simplicity, concurrency, scalability, and productivity. In cloud computing, Go enables the creation of distributed systems handling vast data loads. It's also making strides in machine learning.
For Business Decision Makers:
The business benefits are equally compelling. Choosing the right language can impact development speed, cost efficiency, and ultimately, the bottom line. Rust's memory safety and efficiency reduce the risk of costly security breaches and system failures, safeguarding your business's reputation and financial stability. Go's simplicity accelerates project development, reducing operational costs and improving time-to-market, enhancing your competitive edge.
Both Rust and Go are versatile and powerful languages, but understanding their respective trade-offs and benefits is essential.
Upskilling and Favorite Languages
A recent survey by Heather Joslyn and Lawrence E Hecht posted on theNewStack states Rust and Go to be amongst the most popular programming languages in 2023. The survey is based on responses from 29,269 developers, scattered across 187 countries. It offers a deep dive into not only the tools used by devs and how they use them but also programming languages, work behaviors, salaries, demographics and even the mental health and lifestyles of developers.
Upskilling continues to be important to developers, as the study showed that half of all survey participants said they plan to adopt a new programming language. The top five, in descending order: Go, Rust, Kotlin, Python and Typescript.
Visit Our:
Conclusion
In the Rust vs. Go debate, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. DevOps professionals must weigh factors like performance, safety, and ecosystem support. Business decision makers should consider how the choice impacts development timelines, security, and long-term costs. The key is aligning your language choice with your business specific needs and priorities, whether it's the robust safety of Rust or the rapid development of Go.
Signing Off
Engage with your development and DevOps teams to evaluate which language best suits your upcoming projects. Encourage open communication and collaboration to make informed decisions that align with your business goals. Remember, the right choice today can have a profound impact on your software and therefore your business success tomorrow.
Welcome to our #K8SNation, start your Kubernetes DevOps journey today. Join us! #K8SMastery Courses | Community | Coaching
Comments